RockValues

Herkimer diamond value and identification

Herkimer diamonds are doubly terminated quartz crystals from Cambrian dolostone in Herkimer County and nearby areas of New York, known for their brilliant natural faces and clarity.

A variety of quartz. Prices checked .

Herkimer diamond: Quartz-d06-173a
Quartz-d06-173a. Photo: Robert M. Lavinsky, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Herkimer diamond: Quartz-rhqtz-95a
Quartz-rhqtz-95a. Photo: Robert M. Lavinsky, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Herkimer diamond: Quartz 11
Quartz 11. Photo: Géry PARENT, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

What herkimer diamond is worth

Not enough data. We have not yet seen 5 or more current dealer listings for herkimer diamond in any one form, so we show no range rather than guess.

Show 1 of the listings behind these numbers
Sample dealer listings for Herkimer diamond
ListingSizeLocalityAskingSeen
Quartz var. "Herkimer Diamond"
iRocks (The Arkenstone)
6.2 cmAce of Diamonds Mine, Middleville, Herkimer Co., New York, USA$525

These are dealer asking prices: what shops list herkimer diamond for, not what it sells for and not an appraisal. Selling to a dealer usually brings well below retail, because the dealer has to resell it at a margin.

How to identify herkimer diamond

They are ordinary quartz in chemistry; the name refers to their short, double-pointed habit, natural brilliance and New York origin. See quartz value for the species as a whole.

  • Short, stubby crystals with a point at both ends and 18 natural faces.
  • Very bright, glassy faces that look polished straight from the rock.
  • Often contain black anthraxolite (hydrocarbon) specks, bubbles of fluid or tiny negative crystals.
  • Usually small, from a few millimeters to a few centimeters.
  • Hardness 7; scratches glass.

Other quartz varieties

Where herkimer diamond comes from

Middleville and Herkimer, New York, USA
Fee-dig mines where visitors split dolostone to find pockets of crystals.
St. Johnsville and Little Falls area, New York, USA
Other Mohawk Valley sites in the same dolostone.

Herkimer diamond lookalikes

Diamond

Diamond is hardness 10, much heavier (SG 3.52) and shows strong fire; Herkimers are quartz.

  • Diamond crystals are octahedral, not six-sided prisms
  • Diamond RI 2.42

herkimer diamond vs diamond

Double-terminated quartz from Pakistan, Afghanistan and elsewhere

Usually longer, less brilliant crystals, often with different inclusions; locality is the difference.

  • Same mineral and hardness
  • Often sold as Herkimer type

Also mistaken for herkimer diamond: moldavite, phenakite.

Fake, dyed and treated herkimer diamond

  • Double-terminated quartz from other countries sold as Herkimer diamonds

    Common

    • Long, slender shape or frosted faces
    • No source documentation
    • Bulk lots of uniform crystals
  • Glass 'Herkimer' crystals

    Occasional

    • Molded edges and seams
    • Round bubbles
    • Too symmetric
  • Polished quartz points sold as Herkimers

    Occasional

    • Polishing marks and rounded edges
    • Faces too even

Is my herkimer diamond real? Tests you can do at home

  1. Loupe for natural faces

    Examine the faces under a 10x loupe with light reflecting off them.

    Real
    Natural growth marks and slightly uneven faces with sharp edges.
    Fake or lookalike
    Polishing lines or molded seams.
  2. Scratch test against glass

    Draw a crystal point gently over glass.

    Real
    Scratches glass.
    Fake or lookalike
    Glass imitations barely mark it.

    Can leave a small mark.

A stone that passes these tests is consistent with natural herkimer diamond, not proven. For valuable pieces, a gem lab report settles treatment and origin.

Treatments

None routine (rare)
Herkimers are sold natural; coated 'aura' Herkimers exist and are priced as decorative pieces. Rainbow metallic film.

What moves the price of herkimer diamond

  1. Clarity. Water-clear crystals are the top grade.
  2. Size. Larger crystals are much rarer.
  3. Perfection. Complete terminations without chips or contact points.
  4. Inclusions. Moving fluid bubbles (enhydros) and interesting inclusions add value.
  5. Clusters and matrix. Clusters and crystals on dolostone matrix sell as specimens.
  6. Documented locality. Genuine New York origin is essential to the Herkimer name.

Questions collectors ask about herkimer diamond

Is the Herkimer diamond a real diamond?
No. It is quartz, hardness 7, named for its diamond-like brilliance and double points. Real diamond is hardness 10.
Is the Herkimer diamond worth anything?
Yes, clear, undamaged and larger crystals sell as collector specimens and jewelry stones. Clarity, size, perfection and inclusions drive value; see the price table above.
Where can I sell Herkimer diamonds?
Mineral shows, rock shops, the dealers near the New York fee-dig mines and online mineral marketplaces all buy or list them.

Sources

Prices: 1 current listings from iRocks (The Arkenstone), seen 2026-11-20 to 2026-11-20. How we collect prices.