What herkimer diamond is worth
Not enough data. We have not yet seen 5 or more current dealer listings for herkimer diamond in any one form, so we show no range rather than guess.
Show 1 of the listings behind these numbers
These are dealer asking prices: what shops list herkimer diamond for, not what it sells for and not an appraisal. Selling to a dealer usually brings well below retail, because the dealer has to resell it at a margin.
How to identify herkimer diamond
They are ordinary quartz in chemistry; the name refers to their short, double-pointed habit, natural brilliance and New York origin. See quartz value for the species as a whole.
- Short, stubby crystals with a point at both ends and 18 natural faces.
- Very bright, glassy faces that look polished straight from the rock.
- Often contain black anthraxolite (hydrocarbon) specks, bubbles of fluid or tiny negative crystals.
- Usually small, from a few millimeters to a few centimeters.
- Hardness 7; scratches glass.
Where herkimer diamond comes from
- Middleville and Herkimer, New York, USA
- Fee-dig mines where visitors split dolostone to find pockets of crystals.
- St. Johnsville and Little Falls area, New York, USA
- Other Mohawk Valley sites in the same dolostone.
Herkimer diamond lookalikes
Diamond is hardness 10, much heavier (SG 3.52) and shows strong fire; Herkimers are quartz.
- Diamond crystals are octahedral, not six-sided prisms
- Diamond RI 2.42
herkimer diamond vs diamond
Double-terminated quartz from Pakistan, Afghanistan and elsewhere
Usually longer, less brilliant crystals, often with different inclusions; locality is the difference.
- Same mineral and hardness
- Often sold as Herkimer type
Also mistaken for herkimer diamond: moldavite, phenakite.
Fake, dyed and treated herkimer diamond
Double-terminated quartz from other countries sold as Herkimer diamonds
Common
- Long, slender shape or frosted faces
- No source documentation
- Bulk lots of uniform crystals
Glass 'Herkimer' crystals
Occasional
- Molded edges and seams
- Round bubbles
- Too symmetric
Polished quartz points sold as Herkimers
Occasional
- Polishing marks and rounded edges
- Faces too even
Is my herkimer diamond real? Tests you can do at home
-
Loupe for natural faces
Examine the faces under a 10x loupe with light reflecting off them.
- Real
- Natural growth marks and slightly uneven faces with sharp edges.
- Fake or lookalike
- Polishing lines or molded seams.
-
Scratch test against glass
Draw a crystal point gently over glass.
- Real
- Scratches glass.
- Fake or lookalike
- Glass imitations barely mark it.
Can leave a small mark.
A stone that passes these tests is consistent with natural herkimer diamond, not proven. For valuable pieces, a gem lab report settles treatment and origin.
Treatments
- None routine (rare)
- Herkimers are sold natural; coated 'aura' Herkimers exist and are priced as decorative pieces. Rainbow metallic film.
What moves the price of herkimer diamond
- Clarity. Water-clear crystals are the top grade.
- Size. Larger crystals are much rarer.
- Perfection. Complete terminations without chips or contact points.
- Inclusions. Moving fluid bubbles (enhydros) and interesting inclusions add value.
- Clusters and matrix. Clusters and crystals on dolostone matrix sell as specimens.
- Documented locality. Genuine New York origin is essential to the Herkimer name.
Questions collectors ask about herkimer diamond
- Is the Herkimer diamond a real diamond?
- No. It is quartz, hardness 7, named for its diamond-like brilliance and double points. Real diamond is hardness 10.
- Is the Herkimer diamond worth anything?
- Yes, clear, undamaged and larger crystals sell as collector specimens and jewelry stones. Clarity, size, perfection and inclusions drive value; see the price table above.
- Where can I sell Herkimer diamonds?
- Mineral shows, rock shops, the dealers near the New York fee-dig mines and online mineral marketplaces all buy or list them.
Sources
Prices: 1 current listings from iRocks (The Arkenstone), seen 2026-11-20 to 2026-11-20. How we collect prices.