RockValues

Diamond value and identification

Diamond is pure carbon crystallized in a cubic structure deep in the Earth's mantle and brought up in kimberlite and lamproite eruptions. It is the hardest natural material and has very high brilliance and fire when cut.

Prices checked . Page updated .

Diamond: Cullinan Diamond (replica) (Premier Kimberlite Pipe, Precambrian; Premier Mine, South Africa) 1 (17872546950)
Cullinan Diamond (replica) (Premier Kimberlite Pipe, Precambrian; Premier Mine, South Africa) 1 (17872546950). Photo: James St. John, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What diamond is worth

Not enough data. We have not yet seen 5 or more current dealer listings for diamond in any one form, so we show no range rather than guess.

By variety

Median dealer asking price by variety.
VarietyMedianListings
Blue DiamondNot enough data3
Arkansas diamondNot enough data1
Show 4 of the listings behind these numbers
Sample dealer listings for Diamond
ListingSizeLocalityAskingSeen
Blue Diamond
Trade Roots
1 gUnited States$8
Blue Diamond Nuggets
Trade Roots
1 gUnited States$10
Blue Diamond 37.35 cts.
Trade Roots
37.35 ct$250
Diamond (Rough & Cut) (0.61 ct & 0.23 ct)
iRocks (The Arkenstone)
0.61 ctCrater of Diamonds State Park, Murfreesboro, Pike Co., Arkansas, USA$2,200

These are dealer asking prices: what shops list diamond for, not what it sells for and not an appraisal. Selling to a dealer usually brings well below retail, because the dealer has to resell it at a margin.

How to identify diamond

  • Hardness 10: nothing but another diamond scratches it, and polished facet edges stay razor sharp
  • Very high brilliance with a balance of white light and moderate rainbow fire
  • Single refraction: facet edges seen through the table never look doubled
  • Breath fog on the surface clears almost instantly because diamond conducts heat so well
  • Rough crystals are octahedra, dodecahedra or rounded shapes with a greasy, adamantine luster and triangular growth marks (trigons)
  • Often shows small natural inclusions: dark crystals, feathers or pinpoints under a 10x loupe
  • Grease clings to it and water beads up on a clean surface

Diamond varieties

Where diamond comes from

Botswana (Jwaneng and Orapa)
Among the world's largest producers by value.
Russia (Yakutia)
Largest producer by volume, from kimberlite pipes such as Mir and Udachnaya.
Canada (Northwest Territories)
Diavik and Ekati mines; stones are often sold with Canadian origin marks.
South Africa
Historic Kimberley mines and the Cullinan mine, source of the largest gem diamond ever found and of many blue diamonds.
Argyle mine, Western Australia
Closed in 2020; the main source of pink diamonds and huge volumes of brown stones.
Golconda region, India
Historic source of famous diamonds such as the Hope and Koh-i-Noor; Golconda type stones are known for exceptional transparency.
Crater of Diamonds State Park, Arkansas, USA
The only public diamond site where visitors keep what they find.

Diamond lookalikes

Moissanite

Moissanite is doubly refractive: look through the side of the stone with a loupe and facet edges appear doubled.

  • RI 2.65 to 2.69, more fire than diamond
  • SG about 3.22, slightly lighter
  • Hardness 9.25
  • Passes basic thermal testers; needs a moissanite or multi tester

Cubic zirconia

Cubic zirconia is much heavier: a CZ the same size weighs about 1.7 times as much.

  • SG 5.6 to 6.0
  • Hardness 8 to 8.5, facet edges wear and round
  • RI about 2.15 with strong colorful fire
  • Fails a thermal diamond tester

White zircon

Zircon shows strong doubling of back facets under a loupe and its facet edges chip easily.

  • RI 1.92 to 2.01
  • SG about 4.6 to 4.7
  • Hardness 6.5 to 7.5

white zircon vs diamond

White topaz

Topaz has a glassy look with little fire and is readily scratched by sapphire and diamond.

  • RI 1.61 to 1.62
  • SG about 3.5, similar weight
  • Hardness 8

diamond vs white topaz

Glass

Glass has rounded, worn facet edges and often gas bubbles under a loupe.

  • Hardness about 5.5
  • RI about 1.5
  • Warms quickly in the hand

Also mistaken for diamond: topaz, zircon, goshenite, corundum.

Fake, dyed and treated diamond

  • Cubic zirconia set as diamond

    Very common

    • Heavy for its size when loose
    • Fails a thermal tester
    • Rounded facet edges and scratches on older stones
    • Rainbow fire that looks too colorful
  • Moissanite sold as diamond

    Common

    • Doubled facet edges through the side
    • Passes a basic diamond tester but flags on a moissanite tester
    • Strong rainbow flashes
    • Needle-like inclusions running in one direction
  • Lab-grown diamond sold as natural

    Occasional

    • Passes every home test
    • Girdle inscription such as LG or a lab-grown report number
    • Only a gem lab with spectroscopy can confirm natural origin
  • Glass and rhinestones

    Common

    • Soft, worn facet edges
    • Bubbles
    • Foil backing in costume jewelry
    • Fogs and stays fogged
  • Herkimer diamonds and other trade names for quartz

    Very common

    • Six-sided quartz crystal shape
    • Light weight
    • Low brilliance once compared side by side
  • Coated diamonds and simulants

    Occasional

    • Color sits only at the surface
    • Scratches or worn spots in the coating at facet junctions

Is my diamond real? Tests you can do at home

  1. Fog test

    Clean the stone, breathe on it like fogging a mirror, and count how long the fog stays.

    Real
    Fog disappears almost immediately.
    Fake or lookalike
    Glass, CZ and many simulants stay fogged for a few seconds. Moissanite also clears fast, so this rules out only some fakes.
  2. Loupe check for doubling and edges

    With a 10x loupe, look through the side of the stone at the back facets, then check the facet edges.

    Real
    Single, sharp facet edges; no doubling.
    Fake or lookalike
    Moissanite and zircon show doubled back facets; CZ and glass show rounded or chipped edges.
  3. Combined diamond and moissanite tester

    Use a handheld multi tester that checks thermal and electrical conductivity, touching the probe to a clean facet.

    Real
    Reads diamond.
    Fake or lookalike
    CZ, glass, sapphire and topaz fail; moissanite is flagged separately. Lab-grown diamond still reads as diamond.
  4. Weight compared with size

    For a loose round stone, measure its diameter and weigh it on a carat scale, then compare with standard diamond size charts.

    Real
    Weight matches diamond tables (for example about 6.5 mm for a 1 carat round).
    Fake or lookalike
    CZ of the same size weighs much more; moissanite slightly less.
  5. Read-through test for loose round brilliants

    Place a loose round stone table down on printed text.

    Real
    A well-cut diamond does not let you read the text.
    Fake or lookalike
    Glass, quartz, topaz and sapphire often show readable text. Only valid for standard round brilliants.
  6. Mount stamp check

    Look inside the ring or setting with a loupe.

    Real
    Gold or platinum stamps such as 14K, 18K or PT950 are typical for diamonds.
    Fake or lookalike
    Stamps such as CZ, or 925 in silver settings, strongly suggest a simulant.

A stone that passes these tests is consistent with natural diamond, not proven. For valuable pieces, a gem lab report settles treatment and origin.

Treatments

Laser drilling (common)
Burns tiny channels to reach and bleach dark inclusions, improving apparent clarity; lowers value compared with an untreated stone of the same look. Fine straight tunnels from the surface visible with a loupe; noted on lab reports.
Fracture filling (occasional)
Glass-like filler hides surface-reaching cracks; filled stones sell well below untreated ones and the filler can be damaged by heat or ultrasonic cleaning. Flash effect: blue, orange or pink flashes along cracks when tilting the stone under a loupe.
HPHT treatment (occasional)
High pressure and heat can turn brown diamonds colorless or change them to yellow, green, pink or blue. Gem lab spectroscopy only.
Irradiation and annealing (common)
Creates fancy colors such as blue, green, yellow, pink and black; treated colors sell for far less than natural ones. Gem lab only; some show color zoning at the culet.
Coating (occasional)
Thin films add color or mask a yellow tint; coatings can wear off. Loupe for scratched or patchy coating; lab confirmation.

What moves the price of diamond

  1. Natural vs lab-grown. Natural diamonds and lab-grown diamonds are separate markets; lab-grown sells far lower.
  2. Carat weight. Value rises steeply with size, with jumps at round weights such as half and one carat.
  3. Color. For white diamonds, D to F colorless is top; for fancy colors, saturation and hue decide value.
  4. Clarity. Fewer and smaller inclusions raise value; eye-clean stones are the practical threshold.
  5. Cut quality. Well-proportioned stones with excellent cut grades command more than poorly cut ones.
  6. Treatment. Untreated stones sell well above treated ones of similar appearance.
  7. Grading report. A report from a major lab such as GIA adds confidence and liquidity.
  8. Fluorescence. Strong blue fluorescence can lower the value of near-colorless stones.
  9. Shape. Round brilliants generally bring more than fancy shapes of the same weight.

Care and safety

Diamond can chip along its cleavage if knocked hard. Clean with warm water, mild soap and a soft brush. Avoid ultrasonic and steam cleaning for fracture-filled or heavily included stones.

Questions collectors ask about diamond

Can you tell if a diamond is real with a flashlight?
No. A flashlight shows sparkle and fire, but cubic zirconia and moissanite sparkle as much or more. Use a combined diamond and moissanite tester, a loupe check for doubling, or a lab report.
How do I check if my diamond is real at home?
Check the setting stamp, look at facet edges and back facets with a 10x loupe for wear or doubling, do the fog test, and use a multi tester that flags moissanite. Lab-grown diamonds pass all home tests, so only a gem lab can confirm natural origin.
Do fake diamonds sparkle like real diamonds?
Many do, and some sparkle more. Cubic zirconia and moissanite show stronger rainbow fire, while a diamond shows a balance of bright white light and moderate fire.
Is the Herkimer diamond a real diamond?
No. Herkimer diamonds are naturally double-terminated quartz crystals from Herkimer County, New York; the name refers to their clarity and natural facets.
Can you find diamonds in geodes?
No. Diamonds form deep in the mantle and reach the surface in kimberlite and lamproite; the sparkling crystals in geodes are quartz, calcite or similar minerals.
What is the rarest color of diamond?
Red is generally considered the rarest, with very few pure red diamonds known. Strong natural blue, green and pink diamonds are also very rare.

Sources

Prices: 4 current listings from iRocks (The Arkenstone), Trade Roots, seen 2026-11-20 to 2026-11-20. How we collect prices.