RockValues

Concretions value and identification

A concretion is a hard, compact lump formed inside sediment when minerals such as calcite, silica or iron oxide precipitate and cement the grains together, often around a nucleus like a shell or plant fragment. They are solid all the way through and take the texture of the rock they grew in.

Prices checked . Page updated .

Concretions: Concretions in Colombia - P9151649 (45324113354)
Concretions in Colombia - P9151649 (45324113354). Photo: t_y_l, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What concretions is worth

Not enough data. We have not yet seen 5 or more current dealer listings for concretions in any one form, so we show no range rather than guess.

Show 1 of the listings behind these numbers
Sample dealer listings for Concretions
ListingSizeLocalityAskingSeen
11.8" Flower-Like Sandstone Concretion - Pseudo Stromatolite
FossilEra
30 cm$85

These are dealer asking prices: what shops list concretions for, not what it sells for and not an appraisal. Selling to a dealer usually brings well below retail, because the dealer has to resell it at a margin.

How to identify concretions

  • Rounded, spherical, disc-shaped, dumbbell or knobby forms, often found weathering out of sandstone, shale or clay.
  • Solid inside when broken, with the same grains as the surrounding rock, sometimes in concentric layers.
  • Often harder and darker than the host rock because of extra cement.
  • May have a fossil, shell or plant fragment at the center.
  • Iron oxide types are brown to black on the outside and much heavier than plain sandstone.
  • Fused pairs and clusters (doubles, triples) are common.

Concretions varieties

Where concretions comes from

Navajo Sandstone, southern Utah and northern Arizona, USA
Iron oxide 'Moqui marbles' weather out by the thousand; collecting is banned in national parks and monuments.
Rock City, Ottawa County, Kansas, USA
Giant calcite-cemented sandstone concretions up to several meters across.
Moeraki, Otago, New Zealand
Large spherical septarian boulders on the beach.
Mazon Creek, Illinois, USA
Ironstone concretions that split to reveal Pennsylvanian plant and animal fossils.
Ohio and Kentucky shales, USA
Large concretions in the Devonian Ohio Shale, some containing fish fossils.
Morocco and Madagascar
Commercial sources of polished concretions and septarian nodules.

Concretions lookalikes

Geode

Geodes are hollow and lined with crystals; concretions are solid.

  • Geodes feel light for their size
  • Geodes often have a cauliflower-textured shell

concretion vs geode

Septarian nodule

Septarians are concretions with cracks filled by yellow calcite; plain concretions lack the crack network.

  • Same origin, extra mineral-filled fractures

Meteorite

Concretions show sand grains on a broken or ground face; meteorites show metal flecks and are attracted to a magnet.

  • Iron oxide concretions are not strongly magnetic
  • Meteorites have fusion crust

Thunder egg

Thunder eggs come from volcanic rock and show an agate-filled star-shaped core when cut.

  • Rhyolite shell
  • Center is chalcedony or agate

Fossil eggs

Real dinosaur eggshell shows a thin shell layer with pore structure; concretions are uniform sediment throughout.

  • Most 'dinosaur eggs' found by hobbyists are concretions

Also mistaken for concretions: dinosaur bone, fulgurite.

Fake, dyed and treated concretions

  • Concretions sold as dinosaur eggs or fossils

    Common

    • No eggshell layer on a cut face
    • Grains of sand or mud right through the center
  • Concretions sold as meteorites

    Common

    • Sandy interior
    • No metal flakes
    • No magnet attraction
  • Moqui marbles with doubtful origin or collected from protected land

    Occasional

    • No collection information
    • Claims of national park origin

Is my concretions real? Tests you can do at home

  1. Look at a broken or ground face

    Examine a broken edge or a small polished window with a 10x loupe.

    Real
    Sand or mud grains cemented together, sometimes in rings.
    Fake or lookalike
    Meteorites show metal; geodes are hollow; eggs show a shell layer.
  2. Vinegar drop

    Put a drop of household white vinegar on a hidden spot and watch closely with a loupe.

    Real
    Calcite-cemented concretions fizz slowly.
    Fake or lookalike
    Silica and iron oxide types and meteorites do not fizz.

    Can leave a small mark.

  3. Magnet test

    Hang the piece on a thread and bring a strong magnet close.

    Real
    Usually no pull or a very weak one.
    Fake or lookalike
    Iron meteorites pull strongly.

A stone that passes these tests is consistent with natural concretions, not proven. For valuable pieces, a gem lab report settles treatment and origin.

Treatments

Polishing and cutting (common)
Cut and polished concretions show internal rings or fossils and sell above rough ones. Visible.

What moves the price of concretions

  1. Fossil content. A well-preserved fossil inside, such as Mazon Creek fauna, adds the most value.
  2. Shape and symmetry. Perfect spheres and unusual forms are preferred.
  3. Size. Large intact concretions are heavier to move and scarcer in good shape.
  4. Locality and legality. Documented, legally collected material from known sites sells best.
  5. Finish. Cut and polished pieces showing structure sell above rough ones.

Sources

Prices: 1 current listings from FossilEra, seen 2026-11-20 to 2026-11-20. How we collect prices.