RockValues

Thunder eggs value and identification

Thunder eggs are nodules that form in rhyolite volcanic ash and lava flows. Each has a rough rhyolite shell around a core filled with agate, chalcedony, jasper, opal or quartz, usually in a star or angular shape.

Prices checked . Page updated .

Thunder eggs: Agate-quartz nodule (Buchanan Ranch, Harney County, east of Burns, Oregon, USA) 1 (34762399356)
Agate-quartz nodule (Buchanan Ranch, Harney County, east of Burns, Oregon, USA) 1 (34762399356). Photo: James St. John, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Thunder eggs: Agate nodule (Succor Creek Claim, Harney County, Oregon, USA) (34670752811)
Agate nodule (Succor Creek Claim, Harney County, Oregon, USA) (34670752811). Photo: James St. John, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Thunder eggs: Agate-lined geode (Black Rock Desert, Gerlach, Nevada, USA) (33974978773)
Agate-lined geode (Black Rock Desert, Gerlach, Nevada, USA) (33974978773). Photo: James St. John, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Thunder eggs: Quartz-agate nodule (Killer Green Claim, Ochoco Mountains, Prineville, Oregon, USA) (33993292453)
Quartz-agate nodule (Killer Green Claim, Ochoco Mountains, Prineville, Oregon, USA) (33993292453). Photo: James St. John, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What thunder eggs is worth

Not enough data. We have not yet seen 5 or more current dealer listings for thunder eggs in any one form, so we show no range rather than guess.

These are dealer asking prices: what shops list thunder eggs for, not what it sells for and not an appraisal. Selling to a dealer usually brings well below retail, because the dealer has to resell it at a margin.

How to identify thunder eggs

  • Round to egg-shaped nodule with a rough, knobby, brown or gray rock skin, often with ridges
  • When cut, a star-shaped or angular center of agate, chalcedony, jasper or opal
  • Usually solid or nearly solid, so it feels heavy for its size
  • Shell is fine-grained rhyolite, sometimes showing radial lines toward the center
  • Found weathering out of volcanic ash beds, often in groups
  • Sizes from marble to basketball, most between golf ball and softball

Thunder eggs varieties

Australian thunder egg

Thunder eggs from Australia, best known from Mount Hay in Queensland. The same kind of rhyolite nodule; Mount Hay eggs typically show blue-gray to white agate and brown jasper in star-shaped centers.

Richardson ranch thunder egg

Thunder eggs from Richardson's Ranch, near Madras in Jefferson County, Oregon, including the historic Priday beds. Oregon thunder eggs from one well-known ranch, known for blue agate, plume and fortification centers.

Where thunder eggs comes from

Central and eastern Oregon, USA
The classic source, including Richardson's Ranch near Madras, Succor Creek and the Lucky Strike area near Mitchell.
Mount Hay, Queensland, Australia
Well known Australian thunder eggs with blue-gray and brown agate cores.
Chihuahua, Mexico
Agate-filled nodules from rhyolite such as Las Choyas, often sold as geodes.

Thunder eggs lookalikes

Geode

Geodes are hollow with crystal-lined cavities; thunder eggs are usually solid with a star-shaped filled core.

  • Geodes feel lighter for their size
  • Geodes form in limestone or basalt as well as rhyolite
  • A shake can reveal loose material inside a hollow geode

thunder egg vs geode

Septarian nodule

Septarians have calcite-filled cracks in a gray clay-carbonate body and fizz in vinegar.

  • Softer, hardness 3 to 4
  • Cracks run in a network, not a single star

Concretion

Concretions are solid all the way through with no agate center.

  • Usually sandstone or iron-cemented sediment
  • Layered or uniform interior

Also mistaken for thunder eggs: dugway geode.

Fake, dyed and treated thunder eggs

  • Dyed agate cores

    Occasional

    • Bright unnatural blue, pink or purple
    • Color concentrated in bands or cracks
    • Acetone swab picks up dye
  • Geodes or concretions sold as thunder eggs

    Common

    • Hollow inside
    • No rhyolite shell or no agate core
  • Cut faces sealed with lacquer instead of polished

    Occasional

    • Gloss sits on top and covers pits
    • Shine fades or peels
    • Sticky feel

Is my thunder eggs real? Tests you can do at home

  1. Weight in hand

    Compare with a similar-sized rock.

    Real
    Feels solid and normal to heavy.
    Fake or lookalike
    Hollow geodes feel light for their size.
  2. Cut face check

    Look at the cut face with a loupe.

    Real
    Star or angular filled center with agate or chalcedony and a rhyolite rim.
    Fake or lookalike
    Geodes show hollow crystal-lined cavities; septarians show a crack network.
  3. Acetone swab for dye

    Rub a cotton swab dampened with acetone on the cut face.

    Real
    Swab stays clean.
    Fake or lookalike
    Dyed cores may tint the swab.
  4. Vinegar drop

    Put a drop of household vinegar on the shell and core.

    Real
    No fizzing.
    Fake or lookalike
    Septarian nodules and limestone geodes fizz.

A stone that passes these tests is consistent with natural thunder eggs, not proven. For valuable pieces, a gem lab report settles treatment and origin.

Treatments

Dyeing (occasional)
Adds bright colors to porous agate cores; dyed eggs sell as decor and are worth less to collectors. Unnatural colors and an acetone swab test.
Stabilizing or sealing (occasional)
Fills cracks or adds shine to cut faces; lowers collector value. Loupe for surface film or filled pits.

What moves the price of thunder eggs

  1. Core quality. Colorful, well-defined agate, plume or opal centers bring the most.
  2. Core size relative to shell. A large filled center outsells a mostly rock egg.
  3. Locality. Named Oregon beds and other known localities carry premiums.
  4. Cut and polish. Matched polished halves sell better than uncut eggs.
  5. Size. Large intact eggs and matched pairs are scarcer.
  6. Uncut status. Uncut eggs sell as a gamble and are usually worth less than proven good pairs.

Sources

Prices: no current dealer listings yet. How we collect prices.