RockValues

Septarian nodules value and identification

Dealers list septarian nodules geodes 10 to 20 cm (4 to 8 in) at $125 to $230.

Prices checked . Page updated .

What septarian nodules is worth

Dealer asking prices for septarian nodules, middle half of current listings, checked 2026-11-20. Bar shows the 25th to 75th percentile; the dark tick is the median.
Form and sizeTypical asking priceRange chartMedianListings
Geodes and nodules (per piece)$108 to $240$16514 from 1 dealer
10 to 20 cm (4 to 8 in)$126 to $230$16512 from 1 dealer
Rough (per pound)Not enough data (2 listings, need 5)
Specimens (per piece)Not enough data (1 listing, need 5)
Show 12 of the listings behind these numbers
Sample dealer listings for Septarian nodules
ListingSizeLocalityAskingSeen
Septarian Nodules, Tumbling Rough, per lb (WTumbling)
The Gem Shop
5 lbMexico$10
Septarian Nodules, Tumbling Rough, 5 lb lot (WTumbling)
The Gem Shop
5.1 lbMexico$25
3.5" Polished Septarian Nodule Half - Utah
FossilEra
8.9 cmUtah$29
6.9" Polished Septarian Nodule End-Cut - Utah
FossilEra
17.5 cmUtah$55
7" Polished Septarian Nodule End-Cut - Utah
FossilEra
17.8 cmUtah$55
4.7" Polished Crystal Filled Septarian Nodule Section - Utah
FossilEra
11.9 cmUtah$99
6.1" Polished Septarian Nodule Half - Utah
FossilEra
15.5 cmUtah$135
6.1" Polished Septarian Nodule Half - Utah
FossilEra
15.5 cmUtah$145
5.1" Polished Septarian Nodule Half - Utah
FossilEra
13 cmUtah$165
4.95" Polished Crystal Filled Septarian Nodule Section - Utah
FossilEra
12.6 cmUtah$165
4.65" Beautiful Septarian Nodule Bookends - Utah
FossilEra
11.8 cmUtah$225
5.3" Polished Crystal Filled Septarian Nodule - Utah
FossilEra
13.5 cmUtah$225

These are dealer asking prices: what shops list septarian nodules for, not what it sells for and not an appraisal. Selling to a dealer usually brings well below retail, because the dealer has to resell it at a margin.

How to identify septarian nodules

Septarian nodules are concretions of fine clay and carbonate mud that cracked internally as they formed, with the cracks (septaria) later filled by calcite and sometimes aragonite, barite or other minerals.

  • Rounded to oval nodule with a grey to brown mudstone shell
  • Cut or broken faces show a network of shrinkage cracks filled with yellow, brown or white calcite, often widest toward the center
  • Veins may have a dark brown rim of aragonite or calcite next to the matrix
  • Hollow centers can be lined with calcite crystals
  • Soft: a steel knife scratches both the matrix and the calcite veins
  • Calcite veins fizz slowly with a drop of vinegar

Septarian nodules varieties

Utah septarian

Utah septarians are septarian nodules from Kane County, southern Utah, with grey mudstone matrix, bright yellow calcite and brown aragonite or calcite rims in the cracks. They are known for strong color contrast and are often sold as cut halves showing the yellow calcite network.

Madagascar septarian

Madagascar septarians are septarian nodules from northwestern Madagascar, mostly cut into polished eggs, spheres and freeforms. They usually show grey matrix with brown and white calcite and dominate the polished decor market.

Where septarian nodules comes from

Kane County, southern Utah, USA
Source of Utah septarians with grey matrix, bright yellow calcite and brown aragonite rims; sold whole, cut and polished.
Mahajanga region, Madagascar
Large volumes of polished septarian eggs, spheres and freeforms with grey matrix and brown to white calcite.
Moeraki, New Zealand
The giant Moeraki boulders are septarian concretions on the beach and are protected.
England (Jurassic clays)
Septarian nodules occur in clay cliffs of southern and eastern England.

Septarian nodules lookalikes

Geode

Geodes have a quartz or chalcedony shell and a hollow lined with crystals, but no network of filled cracks.

  • Quartz geodes scratch glass
  • Septarian veins are calcite and soft

Thunder egg

Thunder eggs have a star-shaped agate core inside a rhyolite shell rather than a network of calcite cracks.

  • Agate core scratches glass

Plain concretions

Ordinary concretions are solid all the way through without crack networks.

  • Same origin, without the cracking stage

Fossil turtle shell or dinosaur egg

The polygonal pattern is shrinkage cracks, not plates of bone or eggshell; real fossil bone shows cellular texture under a loupe.

  • Septarian nodules are often misidentified as fossil turtles

Fake, dyed and treated septarian nodules

  • Septarian nodules sold as fossil turtles, dinosaur eggs or dragon eggs

    Common

    • Polygonal crack pattern filled with calcite
    • No bone texture
    • Vein calcite fizzes in vinegar
  • Resin filled or glued nodules

    Occasional

    • Glossy, plastic-looking fill in voids
    • Glue lines along joined halves
  • Dyed or painted calcite veins

    Rare

    • Unnatural bright colors
    • Color on an acetone swab

Is my septarian nodules real? Tests you can do at home

  1. Vinegar drop on the veins

    Put a drop of household vinegar on an unpolished calcite vein and watch with a loupe.

    Real
    Calcite fizzes slowly with tiny bubbles.
    Fake or lookalike
    Resin fill and quartz do not react.

    Can leave a small mark.

  2. Knife scratch

    Scratch a hidden area of a vein with a steel knife.

    Real
    Calcite scratches easily.
    Fake or lookalike
    Quartz filled geodes and thunder eggs resist the knife.

    Can leave a small mark.

  3. Loupe check for fill and glue

    Examine cavities and joins at 10x.

    Real
    Crystalline calcite with natural faces.
    Fake or lookalike
    Smooth glossy resin, bubbles or glue seams.

A stone that passes these tests is consistent with natural septarian nodules, not proven. For valuable pieces, a gem lab report settles treatment and origin.

Treatments

Polishing and shaping (almost always)
Most Madagascar material is cut into eggs, spheres and freeforms; shaping is expected and priced accordingly. Visible polish.
Resin stabilization (occasional)
Fills cracks and voids so pieces survive polishing; lowers collector value slightly. Glossy fill under a loupe.
Oiling or waxing (occasional)
Darkens and enhances contrast on cut faces. Greasy surface feel.

What moves the price of septarian nodules

  1. Pattern and contrast. Bold, well defined crack networks with bright yellow calcite and dark rims stand out.
  2. Crystal centers. Open centers lined with calcite or barite crystals add appeal.
  3. Size. Large whole or polished nodules sell by size and weight.
  4. Locality. Utah material with strong yellow calcite is often sought by collectors; Madagascar material dominates decor sales.
  5. Finish and condition. Even polish without voids, cracks or heavy resin.

Care and safety

Calcite is soft and dissolves in acids. Keep away from vinegar and cleaning products and clean with water and a soft brush.

Sources

Prices: 17 current listings from FossilEra, The Gem Shop, seen 2026-11-20 to 2026-11-20. How we collect prices.