RockValues

Carnelian vs garnet

Carnelian is translucent with a waxy glow and much lighter (SG 2.6); garnet is transparent and heavy.

Side by side

Physical properties that separate carnelian from garnet.
PropertyCarnelianGarnet
Hardness (Mohs)6.5 to 76.5 to 7.5
Specific gravity2.58 to 2.643.57 to 4.32 depending on species
LusterWaxy to vitreousVitreous to subadamantine
StreakWhiteWhite
Crystal systemTrigonal (microcrystalline)Isometric (cubic)
CleavageNoneNone
Refractive index1.53 to 1.541.714 to 1.888 depending on species; singly refractive
FormulaSiO2X3Y2(SiO4)3, where X is Ca, Mg, Fe2+ or Mn and Y is Al, Fe3+, Cr or V
Typical dealer asking price$306 to $469 (tumbled stones)$24 to $141 (specimens)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Fingernail Copper Glass Steel file
Carnelian: Mohs 6.5 to 7. Scratches fingernail, copper, glass, steel file.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Fingernail Copper Glass Steel file
Garnet: Mohs 6.5 to 7.5. Scratches fingernail, copper, glass, steel file.

How to tell them apart

Photos of each

Carnelian

Carnelian: Three oval carnelian cabochons 2
Three oval carnelian cabochons 2. Photo: W.carter, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Carnelian: Iziko Mineral Carnelian
Iziko Mineral Carnelian. Photo: Nkansah Rexford, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Garnet

Garnet: Garnet paragneiss Nuvvuagittuq Greenstone Belt, 4.28 Ga
Garnet paragneiss Nuvvuagittuq Greenstone Belt, 4.28 Ga. Photo: James St. John, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Garnet: Garnetite (grossular garnet skarn) (Middle Eocene, 38-40 Ma; Concepcion del Oro Mining District, northeastern Zacatecas, central Mexico) 1 (15938239901)
Garnetite (grossular garnet skarn) (Middle Eocene, 38-40 Ma; Concepcion del Oro Mining District, northeastern Zacatecas, central Mexico) 1 (15938239901). Photo: James St. John, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

More on each: carnelian value and identification and garnet value and identification.