Agate vs carnelian
Carnelian is orange to red chalcedony, usually unbanded or with faint cloudy bands; strongly banded orange material is called carnelian agate.
Side by side
| Property | Agate | Carnelian |
|---|---|---|
| Hardness (Mohs) | 6.5 to 7 | 6.5 to 7 |
| Specific gravity | 2.58 to 2.64 | 2.58 to 2.64 |
| Luster | Waxy to vitreous | Waxy to vitreous |
| Streak | White | White |
| Crystal system | Trigonal (microcrystalline quartz with some moganite) | Trigonal (microcrystalline) |
| Cleavage | None | None |
| Refractive index | 1.53 to 1.54 | 1.53 to 1.54 |
| Formula | SiO2 | SiO2 |
| Typical dealer asking price | $6.44 to $21 (rough) | $306 to $469 (tumbled stones) |
How to tell them apart
- Identical physical properties
- Much commercial carnelian is heated or dyed agate
Agate shows distinct curved bands; carnelian is mostly even or cloudy.
- Same material; pattern decides the name
Photos of each
Agate


Carnelian


More on each: agate value and identification and carnelian value and identification.