What charlevoix stone is worth
Not enough data. We have not yet seen 5 or more current dealer listings for charlevoix stone in any one form, so we show no range rather than guess.
These are dealer asking prices: what shops list charlevoix stone for, not what it sells for and not an appraisal. Selling to a dealer usually brings well below retail, because the dealer has to resell it at a margin.
How to identify charlevoix stone
- Fine honeycomb pattern of small, many-sided cells packed tightly together.
- Cells have plain centers with no dark 'eye'; walls are thin and pale.
- Looks like plain gray or tan limestone when dry; the pattern appears when wet or polished.
- Side views show long parallel tubes with fine crosswise partitions (tabulae).
- Soft (hardness about 3) and fizzes slowly in vinegar because it is calcite.
- Found as beach pebbles and in limestone along the Lake Michigan shore.
Where charlevoix stone comes from
- Charlevoix, Michigan, USA
- Beaches and road cuts near the town that gives the stone its name.
- Little Traverse Bay and Petoskey, Michigan, USA
- Found alongside Petoskey stones on the same beaches.
- Leelanau Peninsula and Northern Lower Michigan
- Glacially spread pebbles on many Lake Michigan beaches.
- Great Lakes and Midwest limestones
- Favosites is widespread in Silurian and Devonian rocks of Iowa, Ohio, Indiana and Ontario, but only Michigan pebbles are sold as Charlevoix stone.
Charlevoix stone lookalikes
Petoskey stone cells are larger and each has a dark center with radiating lines; Charlevoix cells are small with plain centers.
- Petoskey stone is Hexagonaria, a rugose coral
- Both are Devonian calcite from the same area
charlevoix stone vs petoskey stone
Agatized coral is silica, hard (about 7) and does not fizz in vinegar.
- Florida and Indonesia sources
- Scratches glass
Honeycomb chert or other colonial corals
Silicified material resists a steel knife; other corals show different cell sizes or septa.
- Identification at genus level needs a cut face
Fake, dyed and treated charlevoix stone
Charlevoix stone sold as Petoskey stone, or the reverse
Common
- Check for dark eyes in each cell: present on Petoskey, absent on Charlevoix
Favosites from other states or countries sold as Michigan Charlevoix stone
Occasional
- Silicified material that will not fizz
- Colors unusual for Michigan pebbles
Lacquered or varnished pebbles
Occasional
- Plastic shine that peels at edges
- Pattern visible even when dry because of coating
Is my charlevoix stone real? Tests you can do at home
-
Wet it
Dip the stone in water and look at it in good light.
- Real
- A fine honeycomb of small cells appears.
- Fake or lookalike
- Plain limestone stays featureless.
-
Vinegar fizz
Put a drop of household white vinegar on the back and watch with a loupe.
- Real
- Slow fizzing from calcite.
- Fake or lookalike
- Agatized or silicified coral shows no reaction.
Can leave a small mark.
-
Loupe on cell centers
Look at individual cells with a 10x loupe.
- Real
- Small polygons with plain centers and thin walls.
- Fake or lookalike
- Petoskey stones show a dark center with radiating lines in each cell.
A stone that passes these tests is consistent with natural charlevoix stone, not proven. For valuable pieces, a gem lab report settles treatment and origin.
Treatments
- Hand or machine polishing (common)
- Brings out the pattern; polished stones sell above raw beach pebbles. Visible.
- Coating (occasional)
- Varnish or lacquer shows the pattern without polishing; lowers appeal to collectors. Plastic shine, peeling edges.
What moves the price of charlevoix stone
- Pattern clarity. Clear, even honeycomb across the whole face is preferred.
- Polish. Well-polished stones with no pits or scratches sell above raw pebbles.
- Size and shape. Large, attractive pebbles and pieces suited for jewelry or display.
- Color. Contrasting cell walls and unusual tones add appeal.
Care and safety
Calcite is soft and acid sensitive: keep it away from vinegar-based cleaners and abrasive cloths.