RockValues

Carnotite value and identification

Carnotite is a hydrated potassium uranyl vanadate, a bright canary yellow uranium mineral that coats sandstone, fossil wood and bone. It was a major ore of uranium and vanadium on the Colorado Plateau and is strongly radioactive.

Prices checked . Page updated .

Carnotite: Carnotite in sandstone (Montrose County, Colorado, USA) 2 (23503939706)
Carnotite in sandstone (Montrose County, Colorado, USA) 2 (23503939706). Photo: James St. John, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Carnotite: Carnotite-Vanoxite-sea16b
Carnotite-Vanoxite-sea16b. Photo: Robert M. Lavinsky, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Carnotite: Carnotite-Vanoxite-sea16a
Carnotite-Vanoxite-sea16a. Photo: Robert M. Lavinsky, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Carnotite: Metatyuyamunite-Carnotite-Malachite-214943
Metatyuyamunite-Carnotite-Malachite-214943. Photo: Robert M. Lavinsky, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What carnotite is worth

Not enough data. We have not yet seen 5 or more current dealer listings for carnotite in any one form, so we show no range rather than guess.

These are dealer asking prices: what shops list carnotite for, not what it sells for and not an appraisal. Selling to a dealer usually brings well below retail, because the dealer has to resell it at a margin.

How to identify carnotite

  • Bright canary yellow to greenish yellow powdery or earthy crusts and stains.
  • Usually coats or fills sandstone, petrified wood, fossil bone and other organic debris.
  • Very soft and crumbly (about 2); smears like chalk.
  • Does not glow, or glows only very weakly, under UV light, unlike many other yellow uranium minerals.
  • Reads strongly on a Geiger counter.
  • Visible crystals are very rare; when present they are tiny plates.

Where carnotite comes from

Uravan Mineral Belt, Colorado and Utah, USA
Classic source in Montrose and San Miguel counties, Colorado, and adjoining Utah; mined for radium, vanadium and uranium.
Paradox Valley, Colorado, USA
Type area; carnotite from Roc Creek was described in 1899 and named for French chemist Adolphe Carnot.
Grand and Emery counties, Utah, USA
Temple Mountain and other San Rafael Swell mines produced carnotite in fossil wood and sandstone.
Monument Valley, Arizona, USA
Carnotite ore in channels of the Shinarump sandstone.
Yeelirrie, Western Australia
Large calcrete-hosted carnotite deposit.

Carnotite lookalikes

Tyuyamunite

Tyuyamunite is the calcium analog and cannot be separated from carnotite without lab analysis.

  • Same color and occurrence
  • Often occurs mixed with carnotite

Autunite

Autunite glows bright yellow-green under UV and forms square, flaky plates.

  • Calcium uranyl phosphate
  • Also radioactive

Sulfur

Sulfur forms glassy crystals or crusts, is not radioactive, and is much lighter (SG about 2.07).

  • Pale yellow streak
  • Often near volcanic vents, not in sandstone

Orpiment

Orpiment is orange-yellow with resinous to pearly, flexible flakes and is not radioactive.

  • Arsenic sulfide, toxic
  • SG about 3.5

Yellow ochre (limonite)

Ochre is duller yellow-brown, gives a yellow-brown streak and is not radioactive.

  • Very common iron stain
  • No Geiger response

Fake, dyed and treated carnotite

  • Yellow painted or stained rock sold as uranium ore

    Rare

    • No reading on a Geiger counter
    • Paint sits on the surface rather than soaking into grains
    • Glossy or plastic-like coating
  • Other yellow secondary minerals labeled carnotite

    Occasional

    • Strong UV fluorescence suggests autunite, uranophane or another phosphate or silicate
    • Crystalline crusts rather than earthy coatings

Is my carnotite real? Tests you can do at home

  1. Geiger counter

    Hold a Geiger counter or radiation detector near the specimen, without touching it.

    Real
    Strong reading well above background.
    Fake or lookalike
    Sulfur, ochre and painted rocks read at background.
  2. Longwave UV torch

    In a dark room, shine a 365 nm UV light on the yellow areas.

    Real
    Little or no glow.
    Fake or lookalike
    Autunite and many other uranium minerals glow bright yellow-green.
  3. Visual habit check

    Look at the yellow with a loupe from a short distance without handling it.

    Real
    Earthy, powdery yellow soaking into sandstone grains or wood structure.
    Fake or lookalike
    Paint forms a film; sulfur shows glassy crystals.

A stone that passes these tests is consistent with natural carnotite, not proven. For valuable pieces, a gem lab report settles treatment and origin.

Treatments

Sealing with lacquer or resin (occasional)
Reduces dusting of the powdery coating; collectors generally accept it for safety. Glossy film over the yellow areas.

What moves the price of carnotite

  1. Specimen type. Carnotite replacing petrified wood or fossil bone is more sought after than stained sandstone.
  2. Color intensity. Bright, unaltered canary yellow coatings are preferred over faded or patchy material.
  3. Crystals. Visible crystals are rare and command a premium.
  4. Locality and history. Specimens from named historic Colorado Plateau mines carry collector interest.
  5. Condition. Powdery coatings rub off easily; intact, undusted specimens are worth more.

Care and safety

Carnotite is strongly radioactive and its powder can be inhaled or swallowed. Handle with gloves or tools, never grind, cut or crush it, wash hands after handling, keep it away from children and pets, and check local and carrier rules before shipping radioactive minerals.

Store in a sealed, labeled container away from living and sleeping areas, ideally in a ventilated space. Do not dust, brush or wash the specimen.

Sources

Prices: no current dealer listings yet. How we collect prices.