RockValues

Puddingstone value and identification

Puddingstone is a conglomerate, a sedimentary rock made of rounded pebbles cemented in a finer matrix. The two collector types are Michigan and Ontario puddingstone (red and dark jasper pebbles in white quartzite) and Hertfordshire puddingstone (flint pebbles in silica cement).

Prices checked . Page updated .

Puddingstone: Sample of jasper conglomerate or "St. Joseph Island puddingstone"
Sample of jasper conglomerate or "St. Joseph Island puddingstone". Photo: Kdorse, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Puddingstone: Roxbury puddingstone Boston Franklin Park W 9564 20190501
Roxbury puddingstone Boston Franklin Park W 9564 20190501. Photo: Karlunun, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Puddingstone: Hertfordshire puddingstone at Hertford Museum - 02
Hertfordshire puddingstone at Hertford Museum - 02. Photo: The wub, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What puddingstone is worth

Not enough data. We have not yet seen 5 or more current dealer listings for puddingstone in any one form, so we show no range rather than guess.

These are dealer asking prices: what shops list puddingstone for, not what it sells for and not an appraisal. Selling to a dealer usually brings well below retail, because the dealer has to resell it at a margin.

How to identify puddingstone

  • Rounded, water-worn pebbles set in a finer-grained matrix, like raisins in a pudding
  • Michigan type: red, brown, black and yellow jasper pebbles in white to gray quartzite
  • Hertfordshire type: brown, black and cream flint pebbles in a sandy silica cement
  • Pebbles and matrix are both hard; a good piece breaks through the pebbles rather than around them
  • Takes a polish across both pebbles and matrix when the cement is silica
  • Found loose as glacial boulders and cobbles in the Great Lakes region

Where puddingstone comes from

Drummond Island and the eastern Upper Peninsula, Michigan, USA
Glacial cobbles and boulders of jasper puddingstone, widely collected on beaches and in fields.
St. Joseph Island and Bruce Mines area, Ontario, Canada
The bedrock source of the Michigan type, in Paleoproterozoic Lorrain Formation quartzite.
Lower Michigan and Great Lakes beaches
Glaciers spread pieces south; finds occur far from the source.
Hertfordshire, England
Flint puddingstone from Paleogene deposits, used historically for querns and folklore stones; also found in neighboring counties.

Puddingstone lookalikes

Brecciated jasper

Breccia has sharp, angular fragments; puddingstone pebbles are rounded.

  • Both are silica rocks of similar hardness
  • Clast shape is the main difference

Carbonate-cemented conglomerate

A drop of vinegar fizzes on calcite cement; silica-cemented puddingstone does not.

  • Softer matrix, scratched by a knife
  • Does not polish evenly
  • Crumbles at edges

Concrete with gravel

Concrete has gray cement that a knife scratches and often shows air bubbles and mixed modern gravel.

  • Cement fizzes in vinegar
  • Pebbles are random rock types, not mainly jasper

Fake, dyed and treated puddingstone

  • Ordinary conglomerate or breccia sold as puddingstone

    Common

    • Angular clasts
    • Soft or crumbly matrix
    • Gray, dull pebbles without jasper colors
  • Tumbled or slabbed pieces with a lacquer or wax shine

    Occasional

    • Gloss sits on top of the surface
    • Pits and soft matrix still look shiny

Is my puddingstone real? Tests you can do at home

  1. Look at clast shape

    Examine the pebbles on a broken or cut face with a loupe.

    Real
    Rounded to oval pebbles.
    Fake or lookalike
    Breccia shows sharp, angular fragments.
  2. Vinegar on the matrix

    Put a drop of household vinegar on the matrix between pebbles.

    Real
    Silica-cemented puddingstone does not fizz.
    Fake or lookalike
    Carbonate-cemented conglomerate and concrete fizz.

    Can leave a small mark.

  3. Scratch the matrix against glass

    Try to scratch a glass bottle with a sharp edge of matrix.

    Real
    Quartzite and silica matrix scratch glass.
    Fake or lookalike
    Soft cements do not.

    Can leave a small mark.

A stone that passes these tests is consistent with natural puddingstone, not proven. For valuable pieces, a gem lab report settles treatment and origin.

Treatments

Polishing and tumbling (common)
Brings out pebble colors; well-polished pieces sell better than rough. Not a concern; just check for applied wax or lacquer.

What moves the price of puddingstone

  1. Pebble color and contrast. Bright red jasper pebbles in clean white matrix are the most wanted.
  2. Pebble density. Many evenly spaced pebbles beat sparse ones.
  3. Polish quality. A smooth polish without undercutting adds value.
  4. Size. Large polished boulders and spheres are sought for display.
  5. Origin. Authentic Michigan, Ontario or Hertfordshire material is preferred over generic conglomerate.

Sources

Prices: no current dealer listings yet. How we collect prices.