RockValues

How to tell if a gemstone is real

Most fakes fail one of four cheap tests: a hardness scratch against glass, a weight check for specific gravity, a 10x loupe look for bubbles and curved lines, and an acetone swab for dye.

Start with what fakes are made of

Glass is the most common imitation of nearly every transparent gem. It has a hardness around 5.5, feels warm sooner than crystal, and often shows round gas bubbles and swirl lines under a loupe.

Plastic and resin imitate amber, turquoise and opal. They are light in the hand, soft enough to dent with a fingernail, and some smell of chemicals when touched with a hot needle (a destructive test, only on an inconspicuous spot).

Dyed stones (howlite as turquoise, quartzite as jade, agate in neon colors) carry color that collects in cracks and pits. An acetone swab often picks it up.

Lab-grown stones (ruby, sapphire, emerald, spinel, quartz, opal, diamond) are the same material as natural ones. Home tests rarely separate them; a gem lab report does.

Scratch test against glass

Press a sharp edge of the stone across a clean piece of window glass or a glass bottle. Quartz, topaz, corundum and most gems above hardness 6 scratch glass. Glass imitations, fluorite, calcite and opal do not.

Test on a hidden edge and wipe away powder before judging: a soft stone can leave a streak of its own powder that looks like a scratch.

Specific gravity with a kitchen scale

Weigh the stone dry, then weigh it hanging on a thread fully under water in a cup on the scale (the scale shows the extra weight of displaced water). Dry weight divided by that extra weight is the specific gravity.

Quartz gives about 2.65, glass usually 2.4 to 2.8 (lead glass higher), corundum about 4.0, garnet 3.6 to 4.3, plastic about 1.0 to 1.4. A scale reading to 0.01 g is needed for small stones.

Loupe inspection

Natural stones show angular crystals, feathers and straight color zoning. Round bubbles, swirl marks and molded, rounded facet edges point to glass. Curved growth lines point to flame-fusion lab corundum.

When to pay for a lab report

If a stone would be worth more than the cost of a report (for colored gems that is usually a few hundred dollars of value and up), a lab such as GIA, AGL, SSEF or Gübelin settles natural versus lab-grown, treatment and sometimes origin.

Related guides